top of page
THE TEACUP LETTERS LOGO (6)_edited.png

The gift that shows you

really thought about them.

EXPLORE THE STORIES
Vintage Toronto Mystery Newspaper Collage.png

The Vanishing of Ambrose Small

A historical mystery inspired by one of Canada's most enduring unsolved cases.

ChatGPT Image Oct 15, 2026 at 09_51_20 A

• 3 months of mystery • 13 weekly mailings • $127 CAD + tax

GET THE VANISHING

Postage included. For yourself or as a gift. Choose the start date and add a personal message at checkout.

ChatGPT Image Oct 15, 2026 at 09_51_20 A
Toronto 1919_ Streetcars and Stone Tower
ChatGPT Image Oct 15, 2026 at 09_51_20 A

On December 2, 1919,
Ambrose Small disappeared.

Ambrose Small was one of Toronto’s wealthiest and most notorious theatre owners. He vanished without a trace, leaving behind his wife, his fortune—and a mystery that captured international attention.

​

The Vanishing of Ambrose Small imagines what might have happened to Mr. Small, weaving historical fact with fiction through the private correspondence of two elderly women. Their letters unfold amid rumours and secrets and build toward an ending that

you won't see coming.

ChatGPT Image Oct 15, 2026 at 09_51_20 A
Vintage Toronto Letterhead.png
Pink Poppy Flowers
Minimal Ivory Theatre Mask Divider.png
vertical theatre divider cream.png
GET THE VANISHING
vertical theatre divider cream.png

Tell us who should receive the story.

Minimal Ivory Theatre Mask Divider.png
Choose for yourself or as a gift
1.png
step 3.png

A mystery that arrives
one week at a time...

calendar.png
Choose a start date
2.png

We'll send out the first letter on the day you choose.

Minimal Ivory Theatre Mask Divider.png
step 1.png
Let the mystery unfold
3.png

A new mailing is sent each week for 13 weeks.

Minimal Ivory Theatre Mask Divider.png
Vintage Theater Mask Divider.png

And then comes one final letter...

After the mystery has unfolded, a sealed 13th letter reveals which parts were true, which were fiction, and more about the extrodinary real case behind it all. 

GET THE VANISHING

• $127 CAD + tax • Postage included • For yourself or as a gift

Vintage Sealed Envelope with Gold T Monogram.png
And a Recipe or Two

Vintage recipes tucked into the correspondence offer small glimpses into the everyday world of the women writing the letters.

Newspaper clippings bring the real Ambrose Small investigation into the story, blending historical events with the fictional mystery unfolding in the letters.

News from the Case

Period-style photographs put faces to the story and may give you a reason to look twice.

Photographs With a Past

Follow the correspondence between Margaret and Eleanor as twelve story letters are mailed one week at a time each revealing new details, suspicions, and secrets.

Twelve Private Letters

Over thirteen weeks, your mailbox fills with letters, photographs, newspaper clippings, recipes, and other pieces of the mystery.

Letters, Clippings, and Other Curious Things

ChatGPT Image Oct 15, 2026 at 09_51_20 AM.png

THE VANISHING OF AMBROSE SMALL

Vintage Sepia Parchment Texture.png
Vintage Gold Frame with Wax Seal.png
ChatGPT Image Oct 15, 2026 at 09_51_20 AM.png

Add paragraph text. Click “Edit Text” to update the font, size and more. To change and reuse text themes, go to Site Styles.

First name Last name

I totally wasn't expecting the ending!

WHAT BETA READERS HAD TO SAY

Vintage Theater Mask Divider.png
Vintage Gold Frame with Wax Seal.png
ChatGPT Image Oct 15, 2026 at 09_51_20 AM.png

First name Last name

Add paragraph text. Click “Edit Text” to update the font, size and more. To change and reuse text themes, go to Site Styles.

Vintage Gold Frame with Wax Seal.png
ChatGPT Image Oct 15, 2026 at 09_51_20 AM.png

First name Last name

Add paragraph text. Click “Edit Text” to update the font, size and more. To change and reuse text themes, go to Site Styles.

Vintage Canadian Burgundy Postcard Background.png
Vintage Sealed Letter Bundle Still Life.png
Vintage Ornate Parchment Frame.png
Vintage Ornate Parchment Frame.png
Elegant Pale Gold Floral Divider.png

When You Want to Give Them
Just the Right Gift

A gift they get to open 13 times.

Elegant Pale Gold Floral Divider.png
Vintage Ornate Parchment Frame.png
Vintage Ornate Parchment Frame.png
Vintage Ornate Parchment Frame.png
Vintage Ornate Parchment Frame.png

When You Want to Give Them Just the Right Gift

A gift they get to open 12 times.

We do our homework before we brew the story. Every Teacup Letters mystery begins with research into the real case, time period, and people behind it.

For $97, every story comes with:

12 letters

13th sealed letter that shares the real history behind the story

A tactile experience with thoughtfully chosen paper, envelopes, and period-style details that make each letter feel like part of another time

An original story by Sandra Beatty, editor, copywriter, and published author

Photographs, newspaper clippings, or other historical touches that make the mystery come to life

At least one recipe (because who doesn't love a delicious slice of goodness while reading?)

A 14-day money-back guarantee

Is this a gift? Add your own personal message at check-out and we'll include it in the first letter

See the next story that's brewing

Frequently Asked Questions

  • 01
  • 02
  • 03
  • 04
  • 05
  • 06
  • 07
  • 08
  • 09
  • 10
bottom of page